news

Dissent driven down again

Dissent driven down again

Evo-Stik Northern Premier League

The Evo-Stik Northern Premier League's Respect Manager Phil Bradley believes the league's managers deserve fresh credit for continuing to improve their own standards of behaviour on match days.

As part of the NPL's Respect Programme which this year saw the league win both the Football Association's national league and individual club awards at Steps 1-4, officials have been monitoring 'Technical Area' behaviour for the past three seasons.

Statistics show that dissent is continuing to be driven down and Bradley, who was at the FA Cup Final alongside Respect club winners Nantwich Town to collect the NPL's accolade at the 2012-13 Respect and Fair Play Awards, singled out AFC Fylde for special praise this week when he released the final tables of the campaign.

Referees award behaviour marks of 'excellent', 'good', 'satisfactory’ or 'Poor' and the league's dissent tables are generated by converting the match officials' gradings into numerical marks of three, two, one and minus one respectively.

In the Premier Division AFC Fylde's Dave Challinor and his bench team achieved the remarkable high average over the full season of 2.83 out of a maximum possible three. 'Good' was their minimum score in the 42 league games played.

Not far behind was Kevin Gee and his team at First Division South Rainworth MW with an equally impressive 2.81 out of three. Paul Moore and his staff at Clitheroe led the way in the First Division North with the third best record in the entire league of 2.69, overhauling Lancaster City, who had led the table all season until April in the final month of the campaign.

In the First Division North only Warrington Town averaged below 'good' for the whole season and across the other two divisions there were only nine clubs who didn't average 'good' for the season.

In February the NPL, in conjunction with the Football Association, acknowledged the part played by the vast majority of managers in successfully supporting Respect by sending the three management teams leading the table at that time - AFC Fylde, Lancaster City and Rainworth MW - on expenses paid hospitality packages to Wembley to see England's prestigious international friendly against Brazil.

Bradley said: "The example set by Dave Challinor, Paul Moore and Kevin Gee is fantastic and all Chairmen should be working to ensure their own managers behaviour in the Technical Area is, at the very least, acceptable.

"Since we introduced seminars for managers three years ago they have, by and large, really improved their behaviour in the Technical Area quite dramatically. When we started looking at Technical Area behaviour only around 38 per cent of Tech Areas were receiving 'Excellent' marks from referees for their behaviour and now it is over 48 per cent.

"In the same period there has been a reduction in 'Poor' marks from referees from 3.6 reports of reports to 1.5 per cent so we are slowly but surely improving. Full credit to the managers for achieving that."


Technical Area Marks Season 2012-13

Based on League games only and referee’s marks as follows: 'excellent' three points, 'good' two points, 'satisfactory' one point and 'poor' minus one point

League average – 2.29
Season 2011-12 - 2.20


Premier Division

1 AFC Fylde 2.83
2= FCUM 2.66
2= Marine 2.66
4 Nantwich Town 2.62
5= Hednesford Town 2.52
5= Stocksbridge PS 2.52
7 North Ferriby Utd 2.43
8= Buxton 2.40
8= Blyth Spartans 2.40
10 Ashton United 2.33

- Divisional Average -

11= Eastwood Town 2.24
11= Whitby Town 2.24
13 Kendal Town 2.19
14 Chorley 2.09
15 Worksop Town 2.07
16 Witton Albion 2.04
17 Ilkeston FC 1.95
18 Grantham Town 1.93
19 Stafford Rangers 1.90
20 Matlock Town 1.88
21= Rushall Olympic 1.81
21= Frickley Athletic 1.81 1

Division Average: 2.25
Season 2011-12: 2.14


First Division North

1 Clitheroe 2.69
2 Lancaster City 2.66
3 Skelmersdale Utd 2.64
4 Bamber Bridge 2.59
5 Harrogate Railway Athletic 2.52
6 Radcliffe Borough 2.50
7 Wakefield 2.47
8= Trafford 2.43
8= New Mills 2.43
10= Curzon Ashton 2.38
10= Ossett Town 2.38

- Divisional Average -

12 Cammell Laird 2.33
13 Ramsbottom Utd 2.28
14 Burscough 2.26
15= Garforth Town 2.19
15= Goole AFC 2.19
15= Salford City 2.19
18 Ossett Albion 2.16
19 Prescot Cables 2.14
20 Mossley 2.11
21 Farsley 2.07
22 Warrington Town 1.81

Division Average: 2.34
Season 2011-12: 2.26


First Division South

1 Rainworth Miners Welfare 2.81
2 Halesowen Town 2.62
3= Lincoln United 2.54
3= Chasetown 2.54
5 Brigg Town 2.52
6 Sutton Coldfield 2.50
7= Hucknall Town 2.47
7= Leek Town 2.47
7= Romulus 2.47
10 Sheffield FC 2.40
11 Loughborough Dynamo 2.38
12 Gresley 2.35
13 Mickleover Sports 2.33
14 Northwich Victoria 2.31
15 Carlton Town 2.28

Divisional Average

16 Newcastle Town 2.07
17= Kings Lynn 2.02
17= Stamford AFC 2.02
19 Kidsgrove Athletic 2.00
20 Belper Town 1.95
21 Coalville Town 1.74
22 Market Drayton 1.50

Division Average: 2.28
Season 2011-12: 2.20


‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌